hi,
people joining a thread, discussion, or topic , isnt that inherent of a forum on the internet? <COLOR color=#0000BF>Yes it is, but in this instance your post had absolutely nothing to do with the subject of the thread.
Thats the difference between internet and intranets. <COLOR color=#0000BF>No it is not.
My topics have also been interfered here with many interventions contradicting my viewpoints. I simply reply with arguments, the best thing to do on a forum.
Supported with documents, video footage, arguments. <COLOR color=#0000BF>That is called a discussion; what you have done here is to jump into a thread and post something completely unrelated and irrelevant to the subject.
Do you prefer an accordionists forum that is dominated only by salesmen, or do you want to invite all sorts of accordionists, professionals, amateurs, teachers, producers, dealers, ...? <COLOR color=#0000BF>I do not see any domination by salesmen here. Maybe you have information regarding the membership of this forum that I do not.
Dont you find it odd so little makers and conservatory teachers here on the forum? <COLOR color=#0000BF>No, I do not. This forum grows organically, and we have little say in who joins and uses the forum and who does not. If you wish to go and invite some of them to join then feel free to do so.
The absence of independent, critical accordionists, teachers, ... makes it very convenient for people with commercial and sales interests to have the playground for themselves. <COLOR color=#0000BF>Sorry but I think this is complete twaddle. Its practical when no outside experts can contra argue. I can understand why little effort is made to invite teachers or experts, they could stand in the way of some with commercial interests... <COLOR color=#0000BF>Please see note above regarding forum growth.
A good forum makes sure there are not too many ties between moderators / site administrators and some (privileged?) dealers. <COLOR color=#0000BF>This is the comment that I find really offensive. I will refrain from any further comment on this point, otherwise you would really feel the sharp edge of my tongue!
Dont you think the accordion public is best served with as many independent voices as possible? <COLOR color=#0000BF>Yes
If that is inconvenient sometimes,well thats part of life and growing up. In a mature discussion, one has to be able to criticism, different viewpoints. <COLOR color=#0000BF>But your viewpoint expressed here has absolutely nothing to do with the subject of the thread.
You may call that bad manners, I call it freedom and discussion. <COLOR color=#0000BF>Your initial post on this thread would be deemed bad mannered as you have added nothing and simply hijacked another members thread with an irrelevant diatribe.