Sad / Aeolian / Phrygian Folk Songs

[melasonos]

I seem to be able to find a lot of happy songs in major. I was wondering if anyone could give me a few names of hopefully some traditional Russian or Belarusian songs in a "sadder" key?

Thanks!

 

[godgi]

"the Williow tree". Russia folk Song. i have v gridins sheets. high level of difficulty i am afraid. there are many simplier versions i am sure. v gridins version is on y tube a slow melodic piece of ultimate complexity as yhe piece developes. a masterpiece!

 

[godgi]

a masterpiece by a Genius very very difficult piece but in the hands of master make for inspiration evety time.
enjoy. godgie

 

[godgi]

my favourite piece of accordion music

 

[JeffJetton]

Not traditional (it's from a 1976 Soviet movie), but "Ya Sprosil u Yasenya (I Asked the Ash Tree)" is one of my favorite depressing Russian tunes...

 

[Dingo40]

There's this ?:

 

[Renaldo]

this is a excellent source of Russian, Gypsy, Musette... "Slender Rowan Tree "

 

[melasonos]

Thanks everyone. I wonder what genre this is. Film music? :

 

[melasonos]

Here's the accordion version

 

[Dingo40]

The song is "On the path"
As far as I can tell, it is a popular love song by a known author ( not folk as such)
Sorry to say, like many other examples, it doesn't translate well into English. Pity.
Evocative melody.

 

[melasonos]

The song is "On the path"
As far as I can tell, it is a popular love song by a known author ( not folk as such)
Sorry to say, like many other examples, it doesn't translate well into English. Pity.
Evocative melody.

Yes, from what I gather, it's about a woman who was cheated on and is struggling remembering her time with the man...bitter-sweet kinf of story.

@godgi Thank you for introducing me to Gridin! Amazing pieces he writes!

 

[olivigus]

@melasonos And there is always the option of taking some of those traditionally happy tunes and switching them to minor. Here is an excellent example, that could easily work for an accordion version. (Gives the line "You'll regret it all someday..." a whole new, and rather sinister, meaning.)

 

[melasonos]

@olivigus I like them. I play banjo actually. Good advice. Check this super crazy guy out. It's not really in minor, it's in all keys haha:

 

[olivigus]

I used to love to get groups of people at gatherings to sing a round of Row, Row, Row Your Boat in a minor key. It sounds like a dirge you'd hear on the River Styx. Playing both banjo and accordion? That's pretty impressive.

 

[melasonos]

Well, it would be impressive if I was good. Yeah I really like sea shanties like that too.

 

[cat]

Here's a sad one:

 

[melasonos]

Umm. What. I kinda want to watch it now.

 

[Tom]

Here's a sad one:

Omg, what the heck is this?????

 

[Dingo40]

I have heard mixed marriages can be problematic as expectations can vary!?

 

[cat]

I saw this when it came out in 02, and has remained highly inspirational for me, on many levels. As an aside, my career often involved folk with SDMI - I've had opportunity to play accordions with them.



I should say, it's a rather remarkable film, and fyi deals with violent subjects. No sexual content however, save for this scene where the two civilians portrayed are dear friends, and the sudden objectification is evoked by the insanity around him.