I understand Stepanelli brand has on-the-ground good quality control on Chinese imports
You can buy them from:
or
You can buy them from:
-
-
We're having a little contest, running until 15th May. Please feel free to enter - see the thread in the "I Did That" section of the forum. Don't be shy, have a go!
Chinese Manufactured Accordion Model List
- Thread starter Soulsaver
- Start date
I never heard of Thomann before. I would be interested to hear about them but I am too risk-averse to try one myself. I took home a Chinese-built Hohner Amica for a week one time. It was not bad at all, but it could not compare with my 50-year-old Paolo Soprani. Paolo Soprani is a solid Italian accordion, but it is definitely not a high-end brand; my used one cost $1000 less than a new Amica and was superior to it in every way except one: the new Amica had much quieter mechanics.
Pinu
Member
Prices at Thomann for the startone accordions are pretty interesting:
22/8 - X/X 179€
26/48 - 2/X 419€
34/72 - 3/X 529€
37/96 - 3/4 589€
41/120 - 3/4 749€
41/120 - 4/5 (piccolo) 998€
I added an X when a key info was not displayed in the advertisement. All instruments above are without cassotto.
I add here the link of their website. on the contrary, I am pretty sure most people know Thomann here, since it seems to be the biggest musical instruments supplier in Europe.
I personally bought there a cheap brass sliding trombone fro around 100€ and I was just as good as an equivalent Yamaha of 300-400€. they are obviously no high end Instruments, but, at least my trombone plays pretty decently for that price
22/8 - X/X 179€
26/48 - 2/X 419€
34/72 - 3/X 529€
37/96 - 3/4 589€
41/120 - 3/4 749€
41/120 - 4/5 (piccolo) 998€
I added an X when a key info was not displayed in the advertisement. All instruments above are without cassotto.
I add here the link of their website. on the contrary, I am pretty sure most people know Thomann here, since it seems to be the biggest musical instruments supplier in Europe.
I personally bought there a cheap brass sliding trombone fro around 100€ and I was just as good as an equivalent Yamaha of 300-400€. they are obviously no high end Instruments, but, at least my trombone plays pretty decently for that price
zqd9853572002
Member
I am very sure these video were shot and published at least 20-25 years ago (around 1995-2000), they were just uploaded to youtube recently. The sound is very good for me.
zqd9853572002
Member
Well, Yi is famous, but it is not because he is heavily sponsored by government, it is because he was from "that years" and can still play accordion on the stage (or in another word, he is still young and still has energy to play in different places, this is extremely important). I know some other Chinese accordionists, they have more titles and higher reputation than Yi's from gov, they are also senior than him, but they are not active these 10-20 years due to the age, and it is hardly to find their news
Dingo40
Been here for ages!
Interesting: a "professional playing accordion for children "!
And, under $800 dollars.
And to think some members are spending $29 k.
Something of an overkill?
Hits all the bases!
And, under $800 dollars.
And to think some members are spending $29 k.
Something of an overkill?
Hits all the bases!
zqd9853572002
Member
Seems people have some misunderstanding about the Chinese accordion. Well, Chinese are manufacturing and selling these low-end accordion, but I believe these products' target customer are definitely not professional players, not even the amateur player. Instead, these accordion are for the really beginner (I mean they even have no idea what music/ accordion is), yes, the really beginner who just want to make some noise, and parents also buy these accordion to their kid to play, just "play", like a better, bigger and more formal toy. Once these "player" get know about the accordion (I mean they know they have interest on it and want to spend time to learn it formally), they will buy better accordion of course, because they know these accordion are not good enough to support their playing in future. This scene is just like you go to Staples to buy a pen, you won't investigate what the pen's brand and where it was manufactured, also I bet you won't expect to use the pen every day for 10 years. But if you want to buy a big thing (such as your refrigerator, microwave, washer), you will not go to the dollar store to buy them (just an example, dollar store will also not sell them, lol).
Another thing, I believe the accordion market is similar to other markets, there are always high-end products for professional users, of course, there are also the low-end products to meet mass market. European are taking the lead position in the high end market, but who will fill the low-end market, and will European do that? I don't know...But I am sure Chinese is taking the low-end market, just because of their low cost on manufacturing and they know the low-end is really a mass market.
Another thing, I believe the accordion market is similar to other markets, there are always high-end products for professional users, of course, there are also the low-end products to meet mass market. European are taking the lead position in the high end market, but who will fill the low-end market, and will European do that? I don't know...But I am sure Chinese is taking the low-end market, just because of their low cost on manufacturing and they know the low-end is really a mass market.
People are constantly changing their language by giving new meaning to existing words. It's not just the Russians who are doing it during war times. It's commercial as well. Any item (from accordions to cameras to anything else) that is labeled as "professional" now really means: would NOT be used by people who make a living from this use. So the meaning has simply become the opposite of what it used to be.Interesting: a "professional playing accordion for children "!
And, under $800 dollars.
And to think some members are spending $29 k.
Something of an overkill?
Hits all the bases!
Under the new interpretation of the word "professional" you can indeed get a professional accordion for children without suggesting child labour.
No nuanced amateur options, like tuning frequency or key width, with these fine instruments. Instead these models deliver— in purple!, no less—on the one option real professionals concern themselves with: “What color do you want?!”
Very funny, but o so true!
When I get an accordion in for tuning I sometimes ask things like: what (A4) frequency is it tuned at? and in case I cannot determine what the tremolo was originally set to, how many cents should the tremolo be? Some people could answer the first question. Absolutely nobody could answer the second (unless the answer was zero).
actionsub
Newbie
And I just bought a new kung pao keyboard off Ebay...the brand name is Slade.
trademark.trademarkia.com
SLADE Trademark of Sun Jianjun Serial Number: 86379311 :: Trademarkia Trademarks
SLADE is a trademark and brand of Sun Jianjun
trademark.trademarkia.com
Another one for the list: Monzani.
I think this is made by Golden Cup, also known as the worst accordion manufacturer in the world.
Here is one:
I think this is made by Golden Cup, also known as the worst accordion manufacturer in the world.
Here is one:
Last edited:
forró
Member
I can't comment on the quality (or lack of), but Paloma is another Chinese brand not on the list.
It's very common in Australia. If you search 'Paloma accordion' you will get quite a few results.
It's very common in Australia. If you search 'Paloma accordion' you will get quite a few results.
Add the YingWu (made by Parrot)
Attachments
At least with that name nobody will assume it is European... and of course the "old Scandalli style" register switches scream "made in China" to anyone who knows a bit about design elements that distinguish European from Chinese accordions.
Javthedog
Active member
Looking at chinese manufactured brass instruments, I'm going to suggest that factories in China will manufacture what you want at the price you are prepared to pay. So, you can get high end, good quality stuff as well as nasty stuff. It generally depends on who is doing the importing/ordering and who their target clients are. Some importers will order from a range of factories while others will have a team doing quality control at (probably) one factory. Pretty sure the same applies to accordions.
zqd9853572002
Member
Recently I found accordion is a very typical instrument that could be assembled per your wish and (money). You are right, you can ask them to order some special parts from manufacture and ask them to assemble there. I think is it pretty similar to build your desktop, you can choose the CPU, GPU RAM and monitor model from the market (in accordion world, I even think it is possible to let the manufacture to make a specific "CPU" for you, it might be the only one in the world. One crazy example, you can ask them to put 9 reeds there and make them wet tuned with 20 cents dif...). The shared character is if you pay more, you can definitely get an accordion that fits your needs. If you pay less, you will have to get a mass market product. Seems I got some missed from the topic of this thread....
