Thomas N said:
This is really true. I grew up on Myron Floren, Dick Contino and the like. Lawrence Welk had an edict - you smiled and looked like you were enjoying what you were doing or you were out! Dick Contino was a great accordionist. No way on the level of Frank Marocco or Art Van Damme. But an entertainer he was. You can watch YouTube videos of him throughout his career and he just looked like he was having fun.
I have a deep appreciation for someone's ability to entertain. When I see/hear someone who is very good, it's impressive and laudable, but I understand how it happens (you take lessons, study, and spend a huge amount of time in the woodshed). But when I see someone who is able to really get an audience to have a good time, I just can't figure it out. Where did they learn that? How did they get so good at it?
I remember catching Wayne Newton in Las Vegas once, back when he was in residence at the Stardust. This was several years ago, but nonetheless after his "prime". His voice was completely shot, and his singing was, frankly, lousy. The songs were outdated and the jokes were corny.
And yet it was one of the best shows I've ever seen in my life. I kid you not.
No idea how he pulled that trick of showmanship off. The guy was a master.
UNREAL! I had the same experience! Took my then-girlfriend, now wife, to see Wayne Newton maybe 20 years ago. We sat in a booth crammed in with another couple we didn't know. His show was incredible! At the beginning he announced that he had a cold so it would be hard to hit some notes. The lady sitting with us leaned over and said "he's had that same cold for a decade now".
He ended up going around the audience and wrapped his scarf around my wife. It was hilarious! I recall that he had a young kid on keyboards and guitar that was outrageously good.
Those old-timers really knew how to put on a show!