andrewjohnsson40
Active member
- Joined
- May 21, 2017
- Messages
- 170
- Reaction score
- 1
I have had lessons with two different teacher the last year.
Only one of them talked about how to actually hold my accordion and how to sit. Why is it that some teacher would refrain from talking about ergonomics?
The one who did not talk about ergonomics just asked me to play the accordion. I tried to tell him that I needed more help with how to sit and hold the accordion but he didn't understand what I needed help with.
He plays the chromatic button accordion and I play the piano accordion. It should not matter I think. Perhaps chromatic button accordion doesn't requiere someone to focus on how to hold the accordion. It doesn't happen naturally on the piano accordion.
Is it problematic to have a teacher who plays the chromatic button accordion if you are a piano player?
I mean, RH technique is something he cannot teach but my piano teacher should focus on that...or perhaps I should have a teacher who plays the piano accordion as RH technique is not exactly like it is when you play the piano?
The teacher who talked about ergonomics was a piano player and playes the piano accordion.
So talking about ergonomics is unneccasary for the chromatic button accordion?
On the other hand some singing teachers also refrain from talking about fundamentals. THey just ask you to inhale and sing even if singing requiere a lot of talking about the fundamentals as people can get bad habits.
What do you think is the issue here?
Only one of them talked about how to actually hold my accordion and how to sit. Why is it that some teacher would refrain from talking about ergonomics?
The one who did not talk about ergonomics just asked me to play the accordion. I tried to tell him that I needed more help with how to sit and hold the accordion but he didn't understand what I needed help with.
He plays the chromatic button accordion and I play the piano accordion. It should not matter I think. Perhaps chromatic button accordion doesn't requiere someone to focus on how to hold the accordion. It doesn't happen naturally on the piano accordion.
Is it problematic to have a teacher who plays the chromatic button accordion if you are a piano player?
I mean, RH technique is something he cannot teach but my piano teacher should focus on that...or perhaps I should have a teacher who plays the piano accordion as RH technique is not exactly like it is when you play the piano?
The teacher who talked about ergonomics was a piano player and playes the piano accordion.
So talking about ergonomics is unneccasary for the chromatic button accordion?
On the other hand some singing teachers also refrain from talking about fundamentals. THey just ask you to inhale and sing even if singing requiere a lot of talking about the fundamentals as people can get bad habits.
What do you think is the issue here?